Tuesday, May 5, 2009
Qualities of a Supreme Court Justice
There are a few different things I would like to see in a Supreme Court justice. I don't think a law degree or serious experience as either a lawyer or an employee of the federal government is absolutely necessary when considering a justice candidate. I don't think, however, that experience in some sort of hard working career or job is necessary. I believe a candidate needs the experience of a job that has taught them hard work and has helped them shape informed opinions about our country and life in general. However, I also think a candidate needs to be lenient with his or her opinions. A candidate needs to be open to listening to the different facts of a case so they can pass a democratic judgement that is not necessarily based solely on their previously shaped opinions. Personally, a justice's political affiliation is not as important to me as it is to others, considering I consider myself moderate and an independent. However, I do think I would try to pick a justice who's values are closely aligned with mine, for I may trust their judgement more than a candidates who's values are completely different.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

Well stated, Tori, and thoughtfully considered. Nice job. I like the part about being hard working. I would definitely add intelligence. Grappling with the complexity of the issues that they do and working their way through the precedents established by previous cases is pretty daunting. A high powered, creative and independent intellect which is capable of divorcing itself from self interest is important to me. How do you compare with Pres. Obama? Check out this article: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/03/us/politics/03obama.html?em
ReplyDelete